Opinion · Family law
A diagnosis is not a defect
A person who sought treatment, recovered and entered the marriage with a psychiatrist's clearance deceived no one. In my view, that is how the law of "defects" in the ketubah should be read.
A young man goes through a mental health crisis. He receives treatment, stabilises and returns to a full life: study, work, friends. Years pass. Before the wedding he sees a senior psychiatrist and receives a written opinion: balanced, stable, fully functioning. He consults a rabbi and a doctor, and enters the marriage in good faith.
A few years later the marriage runs aground and the wife asks for a divorce. In the rabbinical court the word "defect" (mum) suddenly appears, and the old diagnosis becomes the reason to order the husband to pay the ketubah and the ketubah supplement (tosefet ketubah), even if, in daily life, it had almost no effect.
In my view this is a mistake, and its cost reaches far beyond a single case. A diagnosis is a word in a medical file. A defect is a reality inside the home. When the two are confused, we punish precisely the person who did the right thing: he sought treatment and recovered.
Let us begin with what the ketubah is for. It is a financial undertaking by the husband to the wife, payable on divorce or death, which the Sages instituted so that she should not be lightly regarded in his eyes, to send her away
(translated).5 Beside the basic ketubah it is customary to write a supplement, a sum the groom undertakes voluntarily, and sometimes a very large one.4 The supplement is given on the assumption that the marriage will last, and the question is what happens to it when the marriage falls apart, and who is responsible. The Mishnah in Ketubot lists situations in which a husband is compelled to grant a divorce and pay the ketubah, and the Shulchan Aruch rules accordingly.12 The examples there are conditions that make shared life unbearable: a repellent illness, an intolerable odour, an occupation that leaves a person outside society. The common denominator is clear. Jewish law does not ask what diagnosis a person has; it asks whether one can live with him. The test is practical, not a label.
That is also why the rabbinical courts themselves are careful. The Great Rabbinical Court rejected a husband's claim that his wife had a mental disorder, holding that he had not brought a shred of evidence
of it, and that mood changes after childbirth are not grounds for losing the ketubah (translated).9 This accords with medicine: according to the Mayo Clinic, most new mothers experience the "baby blues" after birth, a low mood that usually passes within two weeks.22 In the same year, 2022, the Great Rabbinical Court dismissed an appeal by a husband who sought release from the ketubah because his wife had not told him she was taking Cipralex. One of the judges held that the claim of a defect cannot be accepted
, because not everyone who takes Cipralex suffers from a mental disorder
(translated).8 That, too, is medically accurate: according to the manufacturer's official prescribing information, the drug is approved not only for depression but also for panic disorder, social anxiety disorder, generalised anxiety disorder and obsessive-compulsive disorder.2021 And in one sentence that deserves to hang on the wall of every rabbinical court: It is not the name that determines, but the substance
(translated).8
So who determines the substance? Not a judge and not a lawyer, but an expert. Psychiatry itself distinguishes between the two: researchers from the World Health Organization wrote that the international classification of diseases keeps disability separate from the diagnosis of a mental disorder. The diagnosis says what a person has; how far it affects his life is assessed separately.14 Even a psychiatrist is not supposed to give an opinion on a person he has not examined: under the ethics rules of the American Psychiatric Association, it is unethical
for a psychiatrist to offer a professional opinion without conducting an examination (translated).1213 Where the file contains a professional opinion saying "balanced and functioning", and against it there is no medical evidence at all, only a general article about an illness, I see no basis for finding a "major defect". And if one party asks the court to appoint an expert, it is right to grant the request. All the more so where the spouse herself testifies that the condition had no real effect on daily life.
There is also the question of knowledge. According to one view among the halachic authorities, a man who knew of a defect in himself and nevertheless undertook a ketubah supplement is regarded as having accepted the risk in advance, and owes the supplement even when the wife leaves. This reasoning is taken from the laws of the mema'enet (a girl married as a minor who refuses the marriage) and of the muchat shechin (a man afflicted with a skin disease).12 But the whole structure rests on one foundation: knowledge. One who knows he has a defect and conceals it, misleads. One who held a medical opinion that he was healthy, and believed it sincerely, knew of no defect, and no intention to treat his property lightly can be attributed to him. The halakhah shows how decisive knowledge is in the opposite direction too: in a regional rabbinical court in Beer Sheva, a husband claimed that his wife had concealed an eating disorder. The judges held that this is indeed grounds for "a sale in error" (mekach ta'ut) if the husband did not know; but because he knew and carried on living with her, he "thought it over and accepted" (savar vekibel), and was ordered to pay the ketubah.11 And when the element of knowledge falls away, the ordinary rule returns: a wife who initiates the separation without a recognised ground is not entitled to a supplement written on the assumption that the marriage would continue, as follows from the law of "he is repulsive to me" (me'is alai).3
Civil law takes the same approach. In a 2021 judgment written by Justice Yael Willner, the Supreme Court held that there are situations in which non-disclosure before the wedding may give rise to liability, and one of them is non-disclosure of a material and exceptional medical condition that is capable of substantially affecting the lives of the spouses
(translated).6 Note: material, exceptional, and substantially affecting. Not every diagnosis, and not every treatment once received. And in the same judgment the court also held that there is no room to recognise a legal duty of disclosure in respect of intimate and emotional contexts
(translated).67 Here and there alike, it is the actual effect that decides.
To be fair, the strongest counter-argument must be put, and it exists in the case law. In 2020 the Great Rabbinical Court held, in a case where a wife concealed psychiatric treatment, that in Haredi society, the very act of seeking psychiatric and medication treatment is considered a defect that must be reported
, and that the medical diagnosis is irrelevant (translated).10 I respect the argument, but in my view it proves too much. If the stigma itself is the defect, we punish people for having been examined and healed, and we teach the public to avoid treatment. And stigma is indeed a barrier: a review by the Association for Psychological Science concluded that it remains a significant barrier to care,15 professionals in Israel write of "avoiding doing things that could help me" for fear of the consequences,16 and, in the Haredi public, that many still fear and do not seek treatment
(translated).17 Meanwhile the medical facts point the other way: the World Health Organization notes that effective treatments exist even for severe mood disorders,19 and according to the US National Institute of Mental Health, with proper treatment people with such a disorder can lead full and productive lives.18 And the Great Rabbinical Court itself, two years later, took a different path: it is not the name that determines but the substance.8 The claim that "honesty between spouses is a supreme value" is also correct, and I recommend disclosure. But there is a difference between good advice and a penalty. And one who acted in good faith, on the advice of a doctor and a rabbi, is not a deceiver.
What should be done in practice? A person who has had treatment and is about to marry should consult a doctor and a rabbi on what to say and how, and should keep a current medical opinion: it is the best evidence of good faith. A person facing a claim of defect in divorce proceedings should ask for an expert to be appointed rather than argue over the name of an illness, and should check who initiated the separation and why. And those who support such a person should encourage him to seek treatment, not threaten him.
Let us return to the young man at the beginning. He did everything we ask people to do: he sought treatment, stabilised, was examined again before the wedding and asked a rabbi. If, at the end of the road, he is ordered to pay as a "man with a defect" who misled, the message to everyone who is struggling will be devastating: do not get examined, because it will be written against you. Jewish law, in my view, says otherwise, and so does the Supreme Court. A defect is measured at home, not in the file. A diagnosis is a name. A defect is a reality.
Sources
Sources 1–11: Jewish law and Israeli law. Sources 12–22: medicine and psychology. Titles are translated; the sources themselves are in Hebrew unless marked.
- Mishnah and Babylonian Talmud, Ketubot 77a ("these are compelled to divorce"), and in chapter 11, Ketubot 101a (the law of the mema'enet). Full text on Sefaria.
- Shulchan Aruch, Even HaEzer 154 and commentaries (Beit Shmuel there, on the muchat shechin).
- Shulchan Aruch, Even HaEzer 77 (rebellious spouses and "he is repulsive to me"), and Rambam, Laws of Marriage, chapter 14.
- "Ketubot, folio 55: the ketubah supplement", lecture by Rabbi Avihud Schwartz, Yeshivat Har Etzion (2015).
- "The laws of the ketubah, its acquisition and the explanation of its text", Rabbi Avishai Natan Meitlis, Yeshiva.org.il.
- Family Appeal (FamA) 5827/19 Ploni v. Plonit, Supreme Court (Justices Fogelman, Sohlberg, Willner; 2021). Judgment text on the Tel Aviv University Faculty of Law website.
- "When can concealing material information in a relationship ground a claim?", Yehuda Yifrach, Makor Rishon (2021).
- "Sought exemption from the ketubah: 'She concealed Cipralex treatment'", ynet with Psakdin (2022). Great Rabbinical Court.
- "Asked not to be ordered to pay the ketubah because he found a mental disorder in his wife", N12 with Psakdin (2022). Great Rabbinical Court.
- "Haredi woman denied ketubah for concealing psychiatric treatment", ynet (2020). Great Rabbinical Court.
- "Husband told the rabbinical court: the marriage is a 'sale in error'", Kipa (2016). Regional Rabbinical Court, Beer Sheva.
- "The Goldwater Rule: Why breaking it is Unethical and Irresponsible", Dr Maria Oquendo, President of the American Psychiatric Association (APA), 2016 (in English).
- Goldwater rule, English Wikipedia (including views that dispute the rule).
- B. Üstün and C. Kennedy, "What is 'functional impairment'? Disentangling disability from clinical significance", World Psychiatry 8(2), 2009: full article · second publication (in English). The authors state that this is their personal view.
- "Stigma as a Barrier to Mental Health Care", Prof. Patrick Corrigan, Association for Psychological Science (APS), 2014 (in English).
- "Why are most of us still ashamed to see a psychologist?", ynet Health (2017).
- "Overcoming the stigma and treating mental health problems", Dr Moshe Rothschild, Kikar HaShabbat (2013).
- Bipolar disorder fact sheet, Treatment Advocacy Center (2022), quoting the US National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) (in English).
- "Mental disorders", World Health Organization fact sheet (in English).
- Cipralex Summary of Product Characteristics (SmPC), manufacturer Lundbeck, section 4.1 (in English).
- Escitalopram – StatPearls, medical reference database for clinicians (in English).
- Postpartum depression – Symptoms and causes, Mayo Clinic (in English).
The information in this article is general and is not legal or halachic advice. Each case is examined on its merits. The opening scenario is hypothetical.