אטיאס · ATTIAS ATTIAS · אטיאס

Tech, companies and assets

Tax on the division of property

Two spouses can agree on the same number and leave with entirely different sums, because one received cash and the other received shares that will be taxed on the day he or she sells them.

Two questions

Two different questions

The first: is the transfer between the spouses itself a taxable event. The second: must the equalisation take into account the tax that will apply in the future, when the asset is sold. These are separate questions, and each has a different answer [1].

Real estate

A home and rights in land

Section 4A of the Land Taxation Law provides that a transfer of rights in land between spouses under a judgment given in the course of divorce proceedings is not a “sale”. Since Amendment 55 it also applies where the spouses did not ultimately divorce, and to leasehold rights [2].

But the wording is decisive. In 2015 the Appeals Committee in Nazareth rejected an appeal by a woman who had received rights in land from her husband under an agreement that was given the force of a judgment. The committee held that there had been no divorce or separation proceedings, only a property claim, so the exemption did not apply and the woman was charged purchase tax [3]. It follows that the way the agreement is structured and approved is worth money.

Shares

Shares in a private company

The Income Tax Ordinance has no provision parallel to Section 4A, and the definition of a “sale” is broad [1]. The Israel Tax Authority published a tax ruling (7681/14) under which the transfer of shares in a private company pursuant to a divorce judgment is not a sale, on three conditions: the transfer is made by force of the judgment, the recipient “steps into the shoes” of the transferor with respect to the acquisition date and original cost, and the other spouse expressly consents to this [1][4].

The meaning: the tax does not disappear, it is deferred. Whoever receives shares also receives the tax liability that has accrued on them.

Gross or net

An example in numbers

A couple hold shares worth ₪3 million, acquired at no cost, and an apartment worth ₪1 million. A sale of the shares would attract capital gains tax of ₪750,000 (25%). On a gross equalisation, the spouse who keeps the shares pays the other spouse ₪1 million. On a net equalisation he or she pays ₪625,000 [1]. The difference, ₪375,000, is exactly the other spouse’s share of the future tax.

The authors of the article from which the example is taken, including Prof. Shahar Lifshitz, believe that equalisation should be on a net basis [1].

The case law

What the courts have held

  • The Supreme Court

    A remark by Justice Mazuz in Family Appeal Permission 4660/16 was read as establishing a rule of gross equalisation. In Family Appeal Permission 2943/16 he noted that the question is still open [1].
  • The Great Rabbinical Court, 2020

    Net equalisation: from the value determined by discounted cash flow, tax was deducted at the maximum rate of 20% [1].
  • Family Court, Tel Aviv, 2023

    A lawyer who held his activity in a “wallet company”: the wife received half of the value of the company on a gross basis, but she will bear half of the tax when the money is drawn from the company, on the value accrued during the marriage only, and up to five years after the breakdown. Shares in a start-up were divided in kind [4].
  • Regional Rabbinical Court, Tel Aviv, 2023

    Participation in tax was limited to events occurring within three years of the judgment, and was made conditional on security [1].

In practice

What the agreement should provide

  • An express tax clause

    Whether equalisation is on a gross or net basis, and who bears the tax if the asset is sold within a defined period.
  • The transfer route

    Whether the asset passes in kind or is equalised in cash, and whether the transfer meets the conditions for the exemption.
  • Review by an accountant

    Before agreeing on a number, not after.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

If I receive half of the shares, will I pay tax now?

Not necessarily. If the transfer meets the conditions of the tax ruling, the tax is deferred to the date of sale, and is then calculated by reference to the original acquisition date and cost [1].

Which is better for me, shares or cash?

Cash gives certainty and carries no future tax. Shares give a chance of appreciation, but also risk, a tax liability and dependence on the controlling shareholder. Someone who receives shares in a company with debts may also be exposed to its debts [5].

The information is general and is not tax advice. In every case the tax consequences are reviewed with an accountant.

A working meeting with Adv. Attias: 02-5666911 · Contact

Back: Tech, companies and assets