אטיאס · ATTIAS ATTIAS · אטיאס

Tech, companies and assets

Valuation in divorce

In a case involving a company or a business, the great dispute is almost always about the number. The number is set by assumptions, and assumptions can be tested.

Who values

One expert, and a great deal of power

Usually the court appoints a single expert to value the business. According to Adv. Ruth Dayan-Wolfner, judges depart from the expert opinion only in rare cases, and almost all valuers use discounted cash flow (DCF) [1].

Under this method, value is derived from a forecast of future income and a discount rate. A small change in the growth forecast or the discount rate can move the result by millions. The real work is therefore done before the opinion and while it is being prepared: which data are submitted, which assumptions are chosen, and which questions are put to the expert.

When

The valuation date

  • The date of the breakdown

    In most cases shares are valued as of the date of the breakdown of the marriage, and the spouse receives half of the value in cash rather than the shares themselves [2].
  • An earlier date

    In special circumstances the court may value assets as of an earlier date [3].
  • Options

    For options that are not tradable, courts have often preferred the date of actual exercise [4].

After the number

Tax and payment

The pre-tax value of shares is not what their owner will actually receive. Unless the parties agree in advance whether equalisation is on a gross or a net basis, the same number can be worth much less. Tax on the division of property

The law permits the difference to be paid in cash, in kind or in money’s worth, in instalments, against security and with interest. The court takes the spouses’ economic situation into account and seeks to avoid halting or impairing the operation of a company [3]. In a case reported in Globes, the husband was ordered to pay three million ₪, and the court allowed him to pay in instalments over several years [1].

Beyond the company

Earning capacity

The court may depart from equal division having regard, among other things, to future assets and to each spouse’s earning capacity [3]. Where one spouse built a successful career and the other gave up their own, this is sometimes a question worth more than the company itself [5].

In practice

What to prepare

  • Reports and forecasts

    Financial statements, budgets and business plans, including those presented to investors or banks.
  • Agreements

    Founders’ and investors’ agreements, shareholders’ agreements and option plans.
  • Questions for the expert

    A reasoned list of questions and, where needed, a counter-opinion.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

Can both sides agree on one valuer?

Yes, and this saves time and cost. It is worth defining in advance the date, the method and the tax question.

What if the value of the company rose after the breakdown?

This is one of the hard questions. In a case reported in Globes, options worth about ₪100,000 at the time of the breakdown reached about ₪1.3 million after an exit, and the case ended in a compromise [1].

A working meeting with Adv. Attias: 02-5666911 · Contact

Back: Tech, companies and assets